Boris Lvin (bbb) wrote,
Boris Lvin

Мизес о государственном школьном образовании

In countries which are not harassed by struggles between various linguistic groups public education can work if it is limited to reading, writing, and arithmetic. With bright children it is even possible to add elementary notions of geometry, the natural sciences, and the valid laws of the country. But as soon as one wants to go farther, serious difficulties appear. Teaching at the elementary level necessarily turns into indoctrination. It is not feasible to represent to adolescents all the aspects of a problem and to let them choose between dissenting views. It is no less impossible to find teachers who could hand down opinions of which they themselves disapprove in such a way as to satisfy those who hold these opinions. The party that operates the schools is in a position to propagandize its tenets and to disparage those of other parties.

In the field of religious education the nineteenth-century liberals solved this problem by the separation of state and church. In liberal countries religion is no longer taught in public schools. But the parents are free to send their children into denominational schools supported by religious communities.

However, the problem does not refer only to the teaching of religion and of certain theories of the natural sciences at variance with the Bible. It concerns even more the teaching of history from the impact of nationalism and chauvinism. But few people realize that the problem of impartiality and objectivity is no less present in dealing with the domestic aspects of history. The teacher's or the textbook author's own social philosophy colors the narrative. The more the treatment must be simplified and condensed in order to be comprehensible to the immature minds of children and adolescents, the worse are the effects.

<...> It is impossible to deal with any chapter of history without taking a definite stand on these controversial issues and the implied economic doctrines.

  • Сергей Радченко об

    На сегодняшний день самым главным в мире исследователем советской внешней политики послевоенного времени я считаю Сергея Радченко. Каждая его…

  • Высший пилотаж бюрократического языка ЕС

    Как многие, возможно, слыхали, некоторое время назад по разным своим соображениям правительство Газы решило провести очередное военное нападение на…

  • Новый язык новой науки

    Вдогонку к предыдущему. В процитированной аннотации бросилось в глаза словосочетание " “white” people" (как название категории людей, подверженных…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.